58 Old Forest Hill Road in Toronto for sale

Asking price

$6,380,000

Estimate (Sep 19)

$5,913,629

CLICK TO UNLOCK

VIRTUAL TOUR

MLS #:
C13806110 Type:
Detached, 3-Storey Approx. SQFT:
3500-5000 Basement:
Finished

5+1

50.06 x 120.16 ft lot

PROPERTY HISTORY

List Date	List Price	Last Status	Sold Date	Sold Price
0000-00-00	$00000	Lsd	Apr 17, 2015	$12,500
0000-00-00	$00000	Lsd	Dec 07, 2011	$12,500
0000-00-00	$00000	Sld	May 27, 2011	$3,450,000

A Rare Offering On Prestigious Old Forest Hill Road! This Elegant 3 Storey Residence Offers Timeless Character, Gracious Proportions And An Exceptional Family Lifestyle. Hardwood Floors, Classic Millwork, Wainscoting throughout main and second floor. four Fireplaces And An Abundance Of Natural Light. The Spacious Eat-In Kitchen Features A Large Centre Island And Opens To A Sun-Filled Family Room, Multiple Walk-Outs Provide A Seamless Connection To The Private Rear Garden. The Upper Levels Offer Five Generously Proportioned Bedrooms, Including An Impressive Primary Retreat With Fireplace, Ensuite And A Bright Sitting Room Overlooking The garden. Two Additional Bedrooms on third floor with Ralph Lauren Broadloom provides Excellent Flexibility For Family, Guests Or Home Office Use. Finished basement With Recreation Room, Fireplace And nanny's room. Private Backyard Oasis Surrounded By Mature Greenery, Complete With Stone Patio, An Exceptional Setting For Summer Entertaining And Relaxed Family Living. Moments From Forest Hill Village, Parks, Transit And Some Of Toronto's Most Respected Schools, Including Upper Canada College And The Bishop Strachan School. A Wonderful Opportunity To Enjoy A Classic Forest Hill Residence Today, With Outstanding Potential To Personalize And Create A Home For Generations To Come. Check virtual tour for more photos!

Date Listed: Saturday, September 19, 2026
Listing Brokerage: Right At Home Realty - Disclaimer: The information contained in this listing has not been verified by Right At Home Realty and should be verified by the buyer.
Virtual Tour: View Virtual Tour for 58 Old Forest Hill Road
City: Toronto
More 5 bedrooms homes for sale in Toronto
Neighbourhood: Forest Hill South
Major Intersection: Old Forest Hill / Dunloe
Full Address: 58 Old Forest Hill Road, Toronto, M5P 2R2, Canada, ON, Canada
Living Room: hardwood floor, French Doors, W/O To Yard
Kitchen: Limestone Flooring, Centre Island
Family Room: hardwood floor, French Doors, Gas Fireplace
Amenities:
Taxes: $31,344.65 (2026)

Living27 x 13 ft351 sq ft

Dining17 x 13 ft221 sq ft

Kitchen14 x 14 ft196 sq ft

Breakfast11 x 11 ft121 sq ft

Family24 x 17 ft408 sq ft

Primary17 x 15 ft255 sq ft

Sunroom18 x 11 ft198 sq ft

2nd Br15 x 14 ft210 sq ft

3rd Br15 x 13 ft195 sq ft

4th Br15 x 12 ft180 sq ft

5th Br16 x 15 ft240 sq ft

Br12 x 12 ft144 sq ft

Rec24 x 16 ft384 sq ft

Recently sold comparables in Forest Hill South

Sold 49 days ago.

60 St Andrews Gdns

Rosedale-Moore Park, Toronto #C13662946

5+1 BED 6 BATH

$6,000,000

Similar homes for sale

Listed 21 days ago.

199 Arlington Avenue

Humewood-Cedarvale, Toronto #C13761786

5+2 BED 5 BATH

$2,329,000

Estimate (Sep 09) $2,258,810

Listed 22 days ago.

50 Viewmount Avenue

Englemount-Lawrence, Toronto #C13756900

5+1 BED 8 BATH

$3,295,000

Estimate (Sep 08) $3,257,409

Listed 22 days ago.

69 Chaplin Crescent

Yonge-Eglinton, Toronto #C13752432

5 BED 3 BATH

$3,399,000

Estimate (Sep 08) $3,170,511

Listed 15 days ago.

55 Viewmount Avenue

Englemount-Lawrence, Toronto #C13786194

5+1 BED 5 BATH

$3,495,000

Estimate (Sep 15) $3,098,909

Listed 14 days ago.

177A Lyndhurst Avenue

Casa Loma, Toronto #C13790656

5 BED 5 BATH

$3,800,000

Estimate (Sep 16) $3,739,148

Listed 9 days ago.

141 Old Forest Hill Road

Forest Hill North, Toronto #C13813608

5+1 BED 4 BATH

$3,849,000

Estimate (Sep 22) $3,662,809

Listed 106 days ago.

380 Spadina Road

Forest Hill South, Toronto #C13452232

5+2 BED 3 BATH

$3,900,000

Estimate (Jun 16) $3,489,971

Listed 9 days ago.

16 Elderwood Drive

Forest Hill South, Toronto #C13815398

5+1 BED 5 BATH

$3,990,000

Estimate (Sep 22) $3,817,199

Listed 21 days ago.

26 Vesta Drive

Forest Hill South, Toronto #C13759092

5 BED 5 BATH

$3,995,000

Estimate (Sep 09) $3,815,638

Listed 22 days ago.

219 Balmoral Avenue

Casa Loma, Toronto #C13752540

5+1 BED 4 BATH

$4,498,000

Estimate (Sep 08) $3,705,739

Schedule a private showing of this property with an experienced member of our team.

9:30

10:00

10:30

11:00

11:30

12:00

12:30

1:00

1:30

2:00

2:30

3:00

3:30

4:00

4:30

5:00

5:30

I agree to be contacted by By Jesse and Joe Realtor Group via call, email, and text. To opt-out, you can reply 'stop' at any time or click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

SCHEDULE

58 Old Forest Hill Road in Toronto for sale