Listed by Re/Max Experts.

5459 Ontario Avenue is a Fourplex, 2-Storey and is currently for Sale @ $1,198,000. Taxes in 2025 were $6,170.00.

More homes for sale under 1.2M in Niagara Falls

Welcome to 5459 Ontario Ave - A Prime Investment Opportunity in Niagara Falls. The 2-Storey on 5459 Ontario Avenue has 5 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, and is located on a 127.88 x 50.12 ft lot in the community of Downtown . Discover a fullystabilized, cash-flowing asset in one of Canada's most iconic tourist destinations. Thisdetached home features five self-contained 1-bedroom suites and one 2-bedroom suite, offeringsix fully rented units - each partially furnished and occupied by reliable tenants whoconsistently pay on time. Situated on a 50 x 127 ft. lot, this well-maintained propertyincludes two non-conforming basement apartments and rear parking for six vehicles. It providesa turnkey investment with strong rental performance and minimal ongoing management. PropertyHighlights include six fully leased units producing strong, consistent income. Excellenttenants in good standing with a history of on-time payment. 200-amp electrical service and roofreplaced in 2016. This Unbeatable Location is Minutes to Casino Niagara, Clifton Hill, TheFalls, shopping, dining, and entertainment. Quick access to the USA border and Hwy 420.Peaceful residential street surrounded by parks, trails, and campsites. This is a rareopportunity to acquire a fully stabilized, income-producing property in a high-demand rentalmarket with exceptional long-term potential. Perfect for investors looking for reliable cashflow and strategic future upside.

All Existing Electrical Light Fixtures, Six Existing Stoves, Two- Built-in Microwaves with undermounted fan exhaust, Four Existing Fan Hoods, Six Existing Refrigerators.

The address 5459 Ontario Avenue was listed for sale (MLS# X12695386) on Wednesday, January 14, 2026.