Listed by Royal Lepage/J & D Division.

217 Butler Street is a Detached, 2-Storey and is currently for Sale @ $4,999,000. Taxes in 2025 were $28,668.06.

More homes for sale under 5M in Niagara-on-the-Lake

Exceptional opportunity to own a rare estate lot of nearly an acre in the heart of Niagara-on-the-Lake! Beautifully situated on the corner of Queen and Butler with stunning views overlooking the golf course and Lake Ontario. The 2-Storey on 217 Butler Street has 5 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, and is located on a 200 x 138 ft loton .50-1.99 acres in the community of Town . Surrounded by Niagara-on-the-Lake's finest homes. Charming and spacious principal rooms, over 5500 square feet above grade. Tasteful restoration/renovation and additions. This quintessential white clapboard house has a separate Annex with one bedroom, living/dining room, den/bedroom, and kitchen. Multiple fireplaces (both gas and wood). Numerous walkouts to vignettes throughout the garden to follow the sun. Incredible grounds, complete privacy with mature trees, English gardens, a large inground pool, and flagstone patios. Irrigation system and landscape lighting. Steps to Queen Street shops and restaurants. This is a special property that would make a wonderful full time residence or recreational property to invite family and friends to make lasting memories in all the Niagara Region has to offer! **EXTRAS** Former two car garage could be converted back. Koi pond & bubbler (fountain), water softener, built-in speakers, central vacuum and related equipment, fireplace remotes, ductless AC/heat pump (supplemental).

All appliances in two kitchens & two wet bars, washer, dryer, all electric light fixtures, all custom B/Is, ceiling fans, irrigation system, landscape lighting, fenced garden, pool & related equipment (heater 2023)

The address 217 Butler Street was listed for sale (MLS# X12347225) on Friday, August 15, 2025.