365 Cotter Street in Newmarket for sale

Asking price

$529,900

Estimate (Dec 08)

$534,009

CLICK TO UNLOCK

MLS #:
N12610618 Type:
Detached, 2-Storey Approx. SQFT:
1100-1500 Basement:
Unfinished

50 x 175 ft lot

Listed by Re/Max Excellence Real Estate.

365 Cotter Street is a Detached, 2-Storey and is currently for Sale @ $529,900. Taxes in 2025 were $4,057.00.

More homes for sale under 500k in Newmarket

Excellent opportunity for investors or renovators! This spacious 4-bedroom, 2-full-bath home offers incredible potential on a mature lot. The 2-Storey on 365 Cotter Street has 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and is located on a 175 x 50 ft lot in the community of Central Newmarket . Older property in need of updating-perfect for those looking to add value, renovate, or rebuild. Close to essential amenities. Home is being sold in "as-is, where-is" condition.

The address 365 Cotter Street was listed for sale (MLS# N12610618) on Monday, December 08, 2025.

Date Listed: Monday, December 08, 2025
Listing Brokerage: Re/Max Excellence Real Estate - Disclaimer: The information contained in this listing has not been verified by Re/Max Excellence Real Estate and should be verified by the buyer.
City: Newmarket
More 4 bedrooms homes for sale in Newmarket
Neighbourhood: Central Newmarket
Major Intersection: Water St/Prospect St
Full Address: 365 Cotter Street, Newmarket, L3Y 3X9, Canada, ON, Canada
Living Room: hardwood floor, Fireplace
Kitchen: Eat-In Kitchen
Amenities:
Taxes: $4,057.00 (2025)

Living14 x 11 ft154 sq ft

Dining13 x 14 ft182 sq ft

Kitchen16 x 12 ft192 sq ft

Den9 x 9 ft81 sq ft

Laundry15 x 8 ft120 sq ft

Primary12 x 10 ft120 sq ft

Br11 x 9 ft99 sq ft

Br11 x 11 ft121 sq ft

Br14 x 9 ft126 sq ft

Recently sold comparables in Central Newmarket

Sold 4 days ago.

182 Elizabeth Street

St. Patrick's Ward, Guelph #X12577698

4 BED 2 BATH

$500,000

Sold 78 days ago.

3 Basswood Drive

Somerville, Kawartha Lakes #X12310193

4 BED 2 BATH

$505,000

Sold 71 days ago.

514 Bolivar Street

Town Ward 3, Peterborough #X12394519

4 BED 2 BATH

$540,000

Sold 46 days ago.

90 Chaplin Avenue

Downtown, St. Catharines #X12381809

4 BED 1 BATH

$525,000

Sold 5 days ago.

44 Jaffray Street

, Cambridge #X12582180

4+1 BED 2 BATH

$575,000

Sold 63 days ago.

421 13th 'A' Street W

Owen Sound, Owen Sound #X12416578

4 BED 2 BATH

$555,000

Sold 29 days ago.

202 Norwich Avenue

South, Woodstock #X12485763

4 BED 2 BATH

$497,000

Sold 26 days ago.

347 Thiel Street

East H, London East #X12390140

4+1 BED 2 BATH

$522,000

Sold 60 days ago.

1610 ANNE Street

South of Taylor-Kidd Blvd, Kingston #X12330118

4 BED 1 BATH

$510,000

Sold 3 days ago.

284 Helen Street

Central City East, Kingston #X12393669

4 BED 2 BATH

$565,000

Similar homes for sale

Listed 22 days ago.

648 Gorham Street

Gorham-College Manor, Newmarket #N12550262

4 BED 5 BATH

Estimate (Nov 17) $1,245,096

Listed 24 days ago.

386 Handley Crescent

Central Newmarket, Newmarket #N12548344

4 BED 2 BATH

$798,000

Estimate (Nov 15) $783,753

Listed 21 days ago.

601 Mcbean Avenue

Stonehaven-Wyndham, Newmarket #N12556468

4+1 BED 4 BATH

$998,000

Estimate (Nov 18) $1,041,411

Listed 47 days ago.

388 Terry Drive

Central Newmarket, Newmarket #N12479276

4 BED 3 BATH

$999,900

Estimate (Oct 23) $986,937

Listed 53 days ago.

408 Andrew Street

Central Newmarket, Newmarket #N12467621

4+1 BED 3 BATH

$999,990

Estimate (Oct 17) $1,045,406

Listed 34 days ago.

765 Dillman Avenue

Stonehaven-Wyndham, Newmarket #N12515040

4+2 BED 4 BATH

$1,099,888

Estimate (Nov 06) $1,107,282

Listed 67 days ago.

140 Orsi Drive

Gorham-College Manor, Newmarket #N12444224

4 BED 2 BATH

$1,100,000

Estimate (Oct 03) $1,043,186

Listed 52 days ago.

549 Pelletier Court

Stonehaven-Wyndham, Newmarket #N12470008

4+1 BED 4 BATH

$1,149,988

Estimate (Oct 18) $1,123,009

Listed 12 days ago.

611 Heddle Crescent

Stonehaven-Wyndham, Newmarket #N12581170

4 BED 3 BATH

$1,249,000

Estimate (Nov 27) $1,222,006

Listed 63 days ago.

618 Ponting Place

Armitage, Newmarket #N12449734

4 BED 4 BATH

$1,298,000

Estimate (Oct 07) $1,308,609

Schedule a private showing of this property with an experienced member of our team.

9:30

10:00

10:30

11:00

11:30

12:00

12:30

1:00

1:30

2:00

2:30

3:00

3:30

4:00

4:30

5:00

5:30

I agree to be contacted by By Jesse and Joe Realtor Group via call, email, and text. To opt-out, you can reply 'stop' at any time or click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

SCHEDULE

365 Cotter Street in Newmarket for sale